Old School Cool: Your Guide to Classic Motorcycle Insurance

October 9, 2025

Author:

Jon Sevigney

Blog Content

October 9, 2025

Jon Sevigney

Why Classic Motorcycle Insurance Matters for Maine Riders

What Qualifies as a "Classic" Motorcycle?

So, you've got a beloved old bike, perhaps something that rattles and hums with a history all its own. But does it truly qualify for classic motorcycle insurance? It’s not just about how many years it’s been on the road. It’s about a special combination of factors, including its superb condition, any modifications (or lack thereof!), and its overall "collector" status. Think of it this way: not every old car is a classic, and the same goes for our two-wheeled treasures.

Generally, for a motorcycle to be considered a "classic" by insurers, it should largely keep its original manufacturer's look and feel. Heavy modifications can sometimes make things tricky, though some special policies do cover custom builds, especially if they’re older models with significant value. The main idea is to insure a valuable piece of motorcycling history, not just a run-of-the-mill used vehicle.

The Difference Between Classic, Vintage, and Antique

The terms "classic," "vintage," and "antique" often get tossed around interchangeably, but when it comes to insurance, they have specific meanings, mostly based on age. While exact definitions can vary a bit between insurance companies, here’s a general guide:

A Classic Motorcycle is typically a bike that is 20 to 25 years old. Sometimes, insurers might even consider bikes as young as 15 years old, especially if they’re "modern classics" – iconic or rare models that are expected to grow in value. A Vintage Motorcycle usually means a bike that is 25 to 30 years old or even older. These are often bikes that truly capture the spirit of a certain era or design. Lastly, an Antique Motorcycle generally needs to be 35 years old or older to earn this title. These are often significant pieces of motorcycling history, cherished for their heritage.

For us here in Maine, while the state of Maine might have its own classifications for vehicle registration, insurance companies will use their internal rules to decide your policy type and how much you’ll pay. It’s always smart to be very clear about your bike’s exact age and condition when you’re looking for a quote.

Key Differences from Standard Motorcycle Insurance

When we talk about classic motorcycle insurance, we’re not just putting a fancy name on regular coverage. It’s a completely different kind of policy built for a unique type of owner and motorcycle. Here’s why:

The biggest difference comes down to how your bike’s value is figured out. Standard policies usually use Actual Cash Value (ACV). This means if your bike is totaled or stolen, you’ll get its replacement cost minus how much it has depreciated over time. For a classic, this can be a real headache! Imagine your perfectly restored 1970s Triumph, worth a good sum, only to be offered a fraction of its value just because it’s "old." This is where Agreed Value coverage truly shines. With an agreed value policy, you and the insurer decide on your bike's value before the policy even starts. If a covered loss happens, you get that agreed-upon amount, no fuss, no depreciation applied. This peace of mind is truly priceless for anyone who collects these beautiful machines.

What’s more, classic policies usually come with specific rules about how you use your bike. They’re meant for pleasure rides, weekend cruises, club events, and shows – not for your daily commute. This limited use, combined with the fact that classic owners tend to be very careful, is why the premiums are often much lower. You could save a surprising amount, sometimes up to 40% off regular rates, with specialized classic motorcycle insurance.

Eligibility Requirements and Policy Rules

Alright, so your beloved bike is old enough to have some incredible stories, but is it ready for its close-up with a classic motorcycle insurance policy? It's not just about the bike's age; insurers also have specific criteria for you, the rider, and how your cherished motorcycle is used and stored. These rules aren't meant to be a hassle; they actually help keep your premiums lower because they reflect the reduced risk associated with careful owners and their prized possessions.

classic motorcycle stored securely in a garage - Classic motorcycle insurance

Rider and Driving History Qualifications

While your classic motorcycle might be a true work of art, you, the person riding it, are a super important part of the insurance picture. Insurers are looking for responsible riders who show they're a lower risk. Here’s what you can typically expect:

First off, many classic motorcycle insurance providers prefer riders to be a certain age, often at least 25 or even 30+ years old. This is because a little more life experience usually means safer riding habits. You'll also generally need several years of riding under your belt, with some looking for at least 5 to 10 years of licensed driving experience.

A clean driving record is also key. Insurers usually like to see no more than one moving violation or one at-fault accident within the last three years. Don't worry, serious infractions like DUIs usually just need to be at least 10 years old. Plus, many classic motorcycle insurers require that everyone licensed in your household also owns a "daily driver" car. This simply means your classic bike isn't your main way to get around, reinforcing that it's for pleasure, not your everyday commute. For more helpful tips on making sure all your vehicles are properly covered,  check out our insights on More info about auto insurance coverage.

Motorcycle and Storage Requirements

Just like you wouldn't store your cherished antique furniture in a leaky shed, your classic motorcycle needs the right care and a good home to qualify for specialized insurance.

Your bike needs to meet a minimum age, usually at least 20 years old, and often 25 years or older, to be considered for these policies. It should also be in good, original condition or properly restored. This means it should be well-preserved and look largely how the manufacturer intended. Too many wild modifications might make things tricky, but we can always explore options.

Secure storage is a big one! Insurers want to know your prized possession is safe and sound. Most policies require your classic motorcycle to be kept in a fully enclosed and securely locked garage. For very high-value machines, a climate-controlled space can be a real plus. This simple step significantly cuts down the risk of theft and damage. Also, some specialist insurers have minimum value requirements for the bikes they cover, ensuring they're insuring true collector items, like a minimum of $2,000 for a single bike or $1,000 each for a collection of three or more.

Usage Limitations and Appraisals

One of the main reasons classic motorcycle insurance can be so much more affordable is because of specific usage limitations. This isn't the policy for your daily ride down Route 1 to your job; it's for special moments and cherished experiences.

Most classic policies come with annual mileage caps, typically ranging from as low as 2,000 miles a year to up to 7,500 miles annually. While some enthusiast-focused insurers might offer "no fixed mileage restrictions," it's crucial to be honest about how much you plan to ride. Exceeding these limits could affect your coverage. Your bike is meant for pleasure use only. This means leisurely rides along the beautiful Maine coast, perhaps cruising through Wells or Kennebunk, attending club events, displaying your bike at shows, or joining parades. It’s definitely not for regular transportation, like commuting to Portland, or for competitive racing.

Finally, to establish that crucial "agreed value", an appraisal is usually required. This is typically needed when you first get the policy, ensuring the appraisal is no older than 12 months. After that, your insurer might ask for a new appraisal every three to five years. This simple step protects your investment by confirming its true worth and ensures your coverage keeps pace with your bike’s appreciating value.

What Your Classic Motorcycle Insurance Policy Covers

Now for the exciting part: what does classic motorcycle insurance actually protect? It goes far beyond just basic liability. Because your classic bike isn't just transportation, but a passion project, the coverage is custom to safeguard every nut, bolt, and lovingly polished chrome piece.

custom part on a classic motorcycle, like a restored engine or custom seat - Classic motorcycle insurance

Core Coverages: Liability and Physical Damage

Like any motorcycle insurance policy, a classic policy will include essential protections, but with an important twist for physical damage:

  • Liability Coverage: This is the bedrock of any policy and is legally required in most states, including Maine. It protects you financially if you're at fault in an accident that causes bodily injury to others or damage to their property.
  • Agreed Value Coverage: We can't stress this enough – this is the crown jewel of classic motorcycle policies. Unlike Actual Cash Value, which depreciates your bike, agreed value means you and the insurer agree on a specific value for your motorcycle when the policy starts. If your bike is declared a total loss due to theft or damage, you get that full, agreed-upon amount. This ensures your investment is truly protected.
  • Collision Coverage: This covers damage to your classic motorcycle resulting from a collision with another vehicle or object, regardless of who is at fault.
  • Comprehensive Coverage: This is your shield against non-collision incidents. It covers losses due to events like theft, vandalism, fire, falling objects, and natural disasters. Given the value and rarity of classic bikes, comprehensive coverage is usually a must-have.
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage: This protects you if you're involved in an accident with another driver who doesn't have insurance or doesn't have enough to cover your damages.

Just as you'd protect unique pieces in your home, like with Maine Antique Furniture Insurance, classic motorcycle insurance offers a specialized layer of defense for your unique mobile assets.

Specialized Collector-Focused Coverage

This is where classic motorcycle insurance truly shines and separates itself from standard policies. These specialized coverages acknowledge the unique needs and passions of classic bike owners:

  • Accessory and Custom Parts Coverage: Your classic bike might have unique accessories, custom paint, or painstakingly sourced period-correct parts. Many classic policies offer robust coverage for these. For instance, some providers offer $3,000 in accessory coverage at no extra cost, with options to increase up to $30,000.
  • Spare Parts Coverage: Do you have a stash of rare spare parts for your next restoration project? Some policies include coverage for these, often up to $500, protecting them against loss or damage.
  • Roadside Assistance & Trip Interruption: Breaking down on a classic can be an trip, but not always a fun one. Specialized policies often include roadside assistance, towing, and even trip interruption benefits if you're far from home.
  • OEM Parts Guarantee: If your policy includes comprehensive and collision coverage, some insurers guarantee that Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts will be used for repairs, ensuring authenticity.
  • Static Display Cover: For those who love to show off their bikes, this covers your motorcycle while it's on display at an exhibition or show, not just when it's being ridden.
  • Salvage Retention Rights: In the unfortunate event of a total loss, some policies allow you to retain the salvage (what's left of the bike) after a payout, which is invaluable for collectors who want to preserve parts or rebuild.
  • Automatic Coverage for Newly Acquired Motorcycles: Planning to expand your collection? Some policies offer automatic 30-day coverage for newly acquired classic motorcycles, often up to $25,000, giving you time to add them to your policy.
  • European/Cross-Border Cover: If you dream of cruising through Canada or even Europe (for our UK friends, Carole Nash offers European cover for up to 90 days!), some policies extend coverage beyond U.S. borders.
  • Inflation Guard: To account for the appreciating value of some classic bikes, an "Inflation Guard" feature might automatically adjust your agreed value up by a small percentage (e.g., up to 6%) in the event of a total loss.
  • No Amendment Fees for Modifications: Some enthusiast-focused insurers understand that classic bikes are often ongoing projects. They might offer policies with no administrative fees for adding new modifications, encouraging you to keep improving your pride and joy.
  • Track Day Cover (Off-Track): For those with classic race bikes, specialized coverage can protect the motorcycle when it's in transit, storage, or in the shop, but not when it's actively on the track.

These unique coverages ensure that every aspect of your classic motorcycle ownership experience, from the ride to the restoration to the display, is protected. It's truly specialized insurance for your unique treasures, much like the Specialized Insurance for Antiques & Collectibles in Maine we offer for other valuable possessions.

The Cost of Classic Motorcycle Insurance in Maine

"How much will this 'old school cool' set me back?" It's a fair question, and one we hear often! The really good news is that classic motorcycle insurance can often be surprisingly affordable. In fact, it's typically much more budget-friendly than standard motorcycle policies. While some comprehensive policies might start a bit higher, many basic liability policies for a classic bike can be as low as $75 a year! You might even find yourself saving up to 40% off the rates you'd pay for regular coverage.

Why the big difference? It boils down to risk. Owners of classic bikes generally ride them less often, handle them with more care, and almost always store them securely in a garage. These habits translate to fewer claims, which means lower premiums for you. So, whether you're planning leisurely rides along the scenic coastal routes in Wells and Kennebunk, or just enjoying the camaraderie at local bike gatherings in Southern Maine, the cost of protecting your cherished machine might be less than you think.

Factors That Influence Your Premium

Just like any insurance, your premium isn't pulled out of thin air. It's a careful calculation based on several important elements. Understanding these can help you see why your quote looks the way it does:

First off, the motorcycle's agreed value is a big one. A higher agreed value means the insurer is taking on more potential financial responsibility, which typically translates to a slightly higher premium. Then there's the motorcycle type itself. Not all classics are created equal in the eyes of an insurer. A charming vintage moped, for example, will usually cost less to insure than a powerful, classic touring motorcycle or a rare, high-performance antique. This is due to differences in their power, how readily parts are available, and the potential costs if repairs or replacements are needed.

Your location in Maine also plays a role. Where your bike is primarily garaged matters. Postal codes with historically higher rates of theft or accident claims can sometimes lead to slightly higher premiums, even for classics. So, whether your bike calls a quiet town like Ogunquit home, or a busier area like Biddeford, your specific address can subtly influence your rate. Of course, your driving record as a rider is paramount. A clean record with no recent at-fault accidents or multiple tickets will consistently net you the best rates. Insurers want to see that you're a responsible and safe rider.

Finally, your coverage limits and deductible choice will impact your premium. Opting for higher liability limits or adding more specialized coverages will increase your premium. On the flip side, choosing a lower deductible (that's the amount you pay out-of-pocket before your insurance kicks in) will result in a higher premium, because the insurance company pays more if there's a claim. And since classic motorcycle insurance policies are designed for limited use, declaring lower annual mileage (for instance, under 2,000 miles a year) can often significantly reduce your premium.

Common Discounts to Lower Your Rate

We're always looking for ways to save our clients money without compromising on coverage, and the good news is that classic motorcycle insurance policies often come with a variety of discounts! These can really help bring down your premium:

One popular way to save is through a multi-vehicle discount. If you insure more than one classic motorcycle, or even bundle your classic bike policy with your other vehicles (like your car or boat) through the same provider, you can often qualify for a nice discount. Being a member of a recognized classic motorcycle club or enthusiast organization, such as the Antique Motorcycle Club of America, also frequently earns you a motorcycle club membership discount. Insurers tend to see club members as more responsible and engaged riders.

Completing an approved motorcycle safety course demonstrates your commitment to safe riding and can lead to a discount. Installing approved anti-theft devices on your classic bike can also lower your premium, as it reduces the risk of a claim. Many insurers also offer a mature rider discount for experienced riders, which is great given the age requirements for classic policies.

Beyond that, how you care for your bike matters. Storing your motorcycle in a secure, enclosed garage, and consistently demonstrating good maintenance habits, can positively impact your rates. Some insurers even offer discounts for long-term ownership, showing you've been a dedicated caretaker of your classic for an extended period. Lastly, don't forget the power of bundling! Combining your classic motorcycle policy with your home or auto insurance through our agency can often lead to significant savings across all your policies.

For more insights on protecting your valuable collections, including how to potentially save on premiums, explore our articles on Antiques and Collectibles Insurance.

Frequently Asked Questions about Classic Bike Coverage

We hear a lot of questions from our clients about classic motorcycle insurance, and that's great! It means you're being thorough about protecting your passion. Here are some of the most common queries we address, helping you understand how this specialized coverage works.

Is classic motorcycle insurance cheaper than regular motorcycle insurance?

This is a question we get all the time, and the answer is often a resounding yes! It might seem a little odd, given how valuable some of these bikes are, but classic motorcycle insurance can indeed be quite a bit cheaper than a standard policy. In fact, you could see savings of up to 40%!

Why the big difference? Well, it boils down to risk. Owners of classic bikes tend to ride them less often and cover fewer miles each year. They're also usually very careful and meticulous about maintaining and storing their cherished machines. Think about it: a classic isn't typically used for a daily commute through busy city traffic. Instead, it's brought out for leisurely weekend cruises or special events. This limited usage and the careful nature of classic owners make these policies a lower risk for insurers. Plus, while a classic bike is certainly desirable, they’re usually stored so securely it makes them less prone to theft than a more common modern bike. All these factors combine to bring those premiums down. Just keep in mind that for extremely high-value or rare bikes, the comprehensive coverage can still be significant due to the specialized parts and labor needed for repairs.

Are there mileage or usage restrictions on my classic bike?

Yes, absolutely! This is one of the biggest differences between classic motorcycle insurance and a standard policy. These policies are designed specifically for bikes that are cherished items, not your everyday ride.

Your classic motorcycle is meant for pleasure use only. This means it's perfect for those scenic rides around Ogunquit and Biddeford, joining club events, participating in parades, or showing off your beautiful machine at exhibitions. It's generally not covered if you use it for daily commuting to work or school. On top of that, most classic policies come with annual mileage caps. These limits can vary, but you'll often see caps around 2,000 to 7,500 miles per year. Some very specialized policies might offer more flexibility, but it's crucial to pick a mileage plan that truly reflects how much you plan to ride. Going over your agreed-upon mileage could, unfortunately, put your coverage at risk. So, if your plan is to hit the road every single day, a standard policy might be a better fit.

Do I need an appraisal to get classic motorcycle insurance?

In most cases, yes, you will need an appraisal to get classic motorcycle insurance, especially if you want that fantastic "agreed value" coverage. This appraisal isn't just a formality; it's a vital step in protecting your investment.

Think of it this way: the appraisal is a professional, third-party assessment that determines your motorcycle's true market value. This is how you and the insurance company agree on the exact payout amount you'd receive if your bike were to be totaled or stolen. This establishes the agreed value upfront, preventing any frustrating disputes or surprises down the road. Without an appraisal, an insurer might default to "Actual Cash Value," which often means a much lower payout due to depreciation. An appraisal ensures that you're covered for what your bike is truly worth. You'll typically need an appraisal (no older than 12 months) when you first start your policy. And to ensure your coverage keeps pace with your bike's potentially appreciating value, insurers often recommend getting a new appraisal every three to five years. It's a small step that offers huge peace of mind for your prized possession.

Conclusion: Protecting Your Classic Ride in Southern Maine

Owning a classic motorcycle is more than just a hobby; it's a passion, a piece of history, and often, a significant investment. As we've explored, classic motorcycle insurance is specifically designed to protect this unique blend of emotion and asset. From ensuring you receive the true value of your bike with Agreed Value coverage, to offering specialized protections for custom parts and spare components, and even providing peace of mind with roadside assistance, these policies offer a custom fit that standard insurance simply can't match.

The added bonus? Because you're a careful owner who cherishes their ride, limiting its use to pleasure and keeping it securely garaged, you often benefit from lower premiums – sometimes saving up to 40% compared to regular rates. It's a win-win for passionate riders.

Here at Sevigney-Lyons Insurance Agency, we understand the unique bond you have with your classic motorcycle. As an independent insurance agency in Southern Maine, we're deeply rooted in communities like Wells, Ogunquit, Kennebunk, Biddeford, and Portland, and we've been helping our neighbors protect what matters most for decades. We pride ourselves on combining our experience with deep community ties to provide custom insurance solutions for families and businesses across Maine.

With access to over 20 top carriers, we don't just offer you a quote; we offer custom advice, helping you steer the nuances of classic motorcycle insurance to find the perfect policy for your beloved machine. We're here to answer all your questions, ensuring you have the right coverage whether you're cruising the coastal roads or showcasing your pride and joy.

Don't let the complexities of insurance overshadow the joy of your classic ride. Let us guide you to the specialized protection you deserve.

Get your free insurance coverage quote today.

scenic coastal road in Maine with a classic motorcycle on it - Classic motorcycle insurance
coastal insurance group portland maine logoham insurance agency logo south berwick mainelyons agency for insurance kennebunk maine

Contact Us For Personal & Commercial INSURANCE COVERAGE